Should You Hire An In House Graphic Designer or Agency?

It’s a question nearly every growing business faces:

when your brand needs visual consistency, fast execution, and creative direction—do you build a team in-house or bring in the experts?

The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. It depends on your goals, your growth stage, and how design fits into your overall strategy. In this post, we’re breaking down the pros and cons of each approach—and when it might make sense to do both.

‍

The Case for an In-House Designer

Hiring a full-time designer is often the right move for companies with consistent, ongoing design needs. If you’re cranking out social media graphics, internal decks, sales materials, and landing pages every week, having someone in-house can be a game changer.

‍

When it makes sense:

• You need quick turnaround times
• You have a steady stream of small-to-medium design needs
• Your brand identity is established and just needs to be executed consistently
• You want a designer embedded in your company culture and team

Pros:

• Deep knowledge of your brand
• Faster communication and collaboration
• Lower long-term cost for high-volume work

Cons:

• One person can only do so much
• May lack specialized skills (e.g. motion, web design, packaging, brand strategy)
• Harder to scale quickly during high-demand periods

‍

The Case for a Creative Agency

Design agencies are ideal for companies that want access to a full team of creatives—people who bring not just execution, but strategic insight. Whether you're launching a new product, revamping your brand, or building a new website, agencies can give you both the firepower and the perspective to level up.

‍

When it makes sense:

• You’re launching something new or refreshing your brand
• You want a strategic partner, not just a pair of hands
• You need access to a broader skill set (e.g., UI/UX, copywriting, photography)
• You don’t have enough work to justify a full-time role

Pros:

• Access to a team of experts
• High-level creative direction and strategy
• Flexible—great for one-off or seasonal needs

Cons:

• Higher upfront cost
• May require onboarding to learn your brand
• Not ideal for daily, high-volume production tasks

‍

The Hybrid Model: The Best of Both Worlds

More and more companies are choosing to do both. They hire an in-house designer to manage the day-to-day design needs and bring in a creative agency for big-picture strategy and campaign work.

This model works especially well when:

• You want consistency but need bursts of high-level creativity
• You’re growing fast and need to scale output quickly
• You want your internal team to be supported—not stretched thin

An agency can also help build systems, templates, and brand guidelines that make your in-house designer more effective and aligned.

‍

Questions to Ask Before You Decide

• How often do we need new design assets?
• Are we prioritizing speed and consistency—or strategic impact?
• Do we need help executing, or help thinking and building?
• Do we have the budget and infrastructure for a full-time hire?
• Are we looking for long-term support or project-based flexibility?

‍

Final Thoughts

There’s no wrong choice—just the right fit for your needs today. Many companies start with an agency, then bring on an in-house designer. Others do the opposite and bring in an agency later to elevate their brand. The key is being honest about your workload, your goals, and where design can drive the most impact.

And remember: you’re allowed to evolve your model as you grow. That’s the beauty of building a brand that’s built to last.

‍